
It started when Delia turned one…my pursuit of the perfect birthday cake. I am a firm believer that although a box cake is always good, it’s just never as special as a from scratch cake.
For Delia’s first birthday I did a strawberry vanilla cake that was amazing. I spent hours online researching recipes and agonizing over it. Everyone raved and I was hooked, not only on how good it was, but how amazed everyone was that it wasn’t from a box. For her second birthday I made a vanilla coconut cake…again, amazingly delicious. Each year there was a super special cake from scratch to celebrate (although one year she insisted on a kitty, we used store-bought pound cake for the kitty part and one year we did cupcakes instead of a layer cake).
Before Delia was born I hadn’t much luck with home made cakes. In high school, I made a whole wheat chocolate cake. My family laughed as I served it – always the health nut – they just couldn’t fathom why anyone would make a whole wheat cake. The cake was ok…but it was made with pudding instead of frosting. It didn’t occur to me that it needed to be refrigerated, so the next day, after eating a piece that tasted a little odd, I ended up with food poisoning. It was awhile before I attempted a cake from scratch again.
My next attempt was a German chocolate cake for my husband’s birthday – approximately 15 years after my first attempt. The frosting was delicious, but the cake didn’t have a great flavor and the texture was off. His face was so disappointed when he took the first bite…of course he tried to hide it, but obviously he was wishing I’d stuck with the box version. I was in no hurry to try my hand at cake baking anytime soon after.
When Delia was born I remembered all the hand crafted cakes my mother made for our birthdays and really wanted to recreate the specialness. I’ve since fallen in love with making cakes from scratch. For Aiden’s first birthday I searched and searched for the perfect recipe and decided on a vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream frosting from scratch.
Well, let’s just say that it turned out less like the delicious cakes I made for Delia and more like my first attempts. The cake was very dense, more like pound cake, which I really liked but I don’t think everyone else was a fan of (just for the record, Aiden loved it). The frosting however, was another story. I’m not saying that I won’t ever try my hand at buttercream again – but the promise in the recipe that I needn’t worry – just keep whipping and it will come together, never materialized…I assumed just keep whipping didn’t mean longer then 30 minutes, which is about how long I mixed before I gave up. I did use the buttercream, it was just a bit of a disaster…runny and gloppy at the same time…it tasted ok though…thankfully we had Haagen Dazs to go with. This time though, it didn’t deter me…I continued to bake cakes, with much better success.
I made the amazing Beatty’s chocolate cake for my best friend’s birthday last January. If you love chocolate cake, this one was incredible. Then I made Martha’s super yummy red velvet cake for my mother-in-law’s birthday. In October I made the most delicious carrot cake I’ve ever had for my father-in-law’s birthday. I’m pretty much hooked on cake baking at this point, I’m not saying I’ll never make a box cake again, but the rewards of the scratch cakes are hard to deny.
Another birthday is nearing, so, I’ve started searching for the perfect recipe for little Aiden’s birthday number 2. So far the forerunner is the chocolate banana cake from the Betty Crocker cookbook (it’s actually an applesauce cake with banana substituted in). We all love banana bread and I haven’t seen anything else that looks quite as good. I’ll keep you posted on our cake progress….I can’t believe my little monkey turns 2 in two weeks…so sweet!